“What makes Holy Land holy?”

From Scott Adams’ God’s Debris: A Thought Experiment:

“Well, usually it’s because some important religious event took place there.”

“What does it mean to say that something rook place in a particular location when we know that the earth is constantly in motion, rotating on its axis and orbiting the sun? And we’re in a moving galaxy that is part of an expanding universe. Even it you had a spaceship and could fly anywhere, you can never return to the location of a past event. There would be no equivalent of the past location because location depends on your distance from other objects, and all objects in the universe would have moved considerably by then.”

“I see your point, but on Earth the holy places keep their relationship to other things on Earth, and those things don’t move much,” I said.

“Let’s say you dug up all the dirt and rocks and vegetation of a holy place and moved it someplace else, leaving nothing but a hole that is one mile deep in the original location. Would the holy land now be the new location where you put the dirt and rocks and vegetation, or the old location with the hole?”

“I think both would be considered holy,” I said, hedging my bets.

“Suppose you took only the very top layer of soil and and vegetation from holy place, the newer stuff that blew in or grew after the religious event occurred thousands of years ago. Would the place you dumped the topsoil and vegetation be holy?”

“That’s a little trickier,” I said. “I’ll say the new location isn’t holy because the topsoil that you moved there isn’t itself holy, it was only in contact with holy land. If holy land could turn anything that touched it into more holy land, then the whole planet would be holy.”

The old man smiled. “The concept of location is a useful delusion when applied to real estate ownership, or when giving someone directions to the store. But when it is viewed through the eyes of an omnipotent God, the concept of location is absurd.

“While we speak, nations are arming themselves to fight for control of lands they consider holy. They are trapped in the delusion that locations are real things, not just fictions of the mind. Many will die.”

4 thoughts on ““What makes Holy Land holy?”

  1. What would be the attributes of Holy or Sacred ground? Was it just an event that people experienced there as a miracle? Would there me any physical manifestations? Like what the ground is made of, what may be under the ground? Has anyone checked for energy levels to see if it is a place that puts out frequency that can be detected? What is it that would cause a complete stranger who knows nothing of a history of any sort, to stop and say, “this is sacred ground”. I have had this event happen and I am most curious to know what you have found.
    — Melinda

  2. I was just trying to answer the original question using the omnipotent God’s own words. According to scripture (uh-oh there’s that word again)…those are his words, not mine. That is why God called land holy. You can call any land or any people holy if u want to, does that make it holy? But if God calls it that way, that settles it for me.

  3. In reply to Mr/Ms Wonka:

    “scripture says it is because God is there.”

    Okay. But isn’t God omnipresent? Not just hovering over Jerusalem, but equally present in Tokyo and Scranton, PA. And Jupiter and Alpha Centauri.

    “because God dwelt among His people”

    Aren’t all people –even the Eskimos– “His people?” When God was dwelling in Canan, for example, wasn’t he also living in a village in India?

  4. To answer the original question, “What makes holy land Holy?”, scripture says it is because God is there. Moses was told to remove his shoes at Mt Sinai because he was on holy ground…because God was there. Israel was/is called the Holy Land because God dwelt among His people…he was there. According to scripture, God’s presence is what made the land holy. Not the dirt, duh.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *